Home » Blog » Hiring » How top CEOs hire talent
Hiring
3 min read

How top CEOs hire talent

While people often think hiring falls squarely on HR, recent research shows that it tops the list of issues CEOs worry about. In fact, “finding the right talent” was cited as the most common challenge CEOs face.

Senior leadership is ultimately responsible for ensuring that people strategy lines up with business strategy to create optimal results—and this means hiring top talent and building high-performing teams.

The Predictive Index® recently conducted a survey of more than 150 CEOs to determine what CEOs’ priorities are in 2019 and what top-performing CEOs are doing differently to generate better results. Here’s what we found:

58% of high-performing CEOs use tools to assess job fit and team fit.

Our research found that high-performing CEOs are less likely to rely on intuition when it comes to hiring and more likely to implement tools that help them evaluate whether a candidate is the right fit for the role and team.

These tools allow them to make objective hiring decisions and leverage science to better predict job success.

Tips for choosing the right tools to ensure job fit and team fit:

  1. Make sure the tool is scientifically validated for your use case. Any pre- or post-hire tool you implement should be scientifically validated—period. Beyond that, it should be validated for your particular use case. For example, while the DiSC assessment is widely used for managing interpersonal dynamics post-hire, it’s not recommended for pre-hire use, because it doesn’t predict job performance or measure a skill, aptitude, or factor that’s specific to a role.
  2. Pick a tool that measures what you need to measure for the job. For example, if a position requires a new hire to onboard quickly or to rapidly adapt to changing technology or market trends, you might require a cognitive assessment, which measures an individual’s ability to learn, adapt, and manage complexity. A behavioral assessment, on the other hand, would not be an appropriate tool for this use case.
  3. Choose a reputable tool that backs its claims. Just because a tool has a great website or a roster of big-name clients, that doesn’t mean the tool is accurate or works well. Dig deeper to find research supporting their claims, and take time to read product reviews from real customers on sites such as G2 Crowd to get insight about how well the product performs on its promises.

Hiring is something successful CEOs don’t leave to gut feel alone. They rely on objective science and data to help them make the right decision.

Join 10,000 companies solving the most complex people problems with PI.

The latest from our blog

Leadership

9 Key Leadership Skills for 2026

Read our deep dive into the essential leadership skills that differentiate good and successful leaders from all the...

Employee Engagement

Your people started motivated. Here’s what changed.

78% of employees start motivated, yet disengagement is everywhere. New survey data reveals the real culprits — and...

Employee Engagement

Is efficiency actually driving engagement (or quietly killing it?)

Employees start motivated but lose meaning at work. PI's new survey data shows how distraction, unclear priorities, and...

Leadership

From Scrolling to Strategy: How to Cure Reactive Leadership

Leaders are making faster, more reactive decisions. Learn how to build discernment, manage attention, and lead with depth...

Company Culture

How to prevent AI from fragmenting your workplace culture

Most organizations are moving fast with AI adoption- maybe faster than their teams are ready for. The result...

Uncategorized

2026 Predicted: 4 signals of what’s to come this year

In hindsight, 2025 may be remembered as the year talent strategy stopped being theoretical. Artificial intelligence moved from...

Hiring

The Best Candidates Can’t Find You. Here’s Why.

Stop hiding your roles behind creative titles. Learn how to optimize job descriptions for SEO, LinkedIn, and LLMs...

Artificial Intelligence

Will AI Replace HR Managers? Staying Relevant in an AI-First World

Explore how AI is changing, not replacing, HR, which functions are automated, new roles, and how HR managers...

Company Culture

Top Employee Retention Strategies for 2026: How to Retain Your Best Talent

Struggling with employee turnover? Explore effective ways to retain staff and build a high-performing team using proven techniques...

Back to top
Copy link