Home » Blog » Hiring » Don’t let your managers throw their new employees to the wolves: Guidelines for successful onboarding
Hiring
3 min read

Don’t let your managers throw their new employees to the wolves: Guidelines for successful onboarding

By Greg Barnett, PhD

We’re all busy. We all have too much to do and not enough time to do it.

So when one of your managers hires competent, independent, self-driven employees, it’s easy for him or her to let those employees find their own way. The truth is, as tempting as it may be to just throw those new employees to the wolves, managers really shouldn’t.

Their absolute first priority is to take care of their new employees. Nothing is more important than getting the people part right.  As they say “you don’t get a second chance for a first impression” and in fact, companies only have a small period of time to show new talent that they understand them and truly care. If they aren’t paying close enough attention, new employees will feel disconnected from the organization, its mission, and its people and this can create disengagement that can never be overcome. 

So what can you do?

One of the first things to recognize is that not all managers are comfortable or experienced on how to onboard employees better. They need tips on how to effectively manage their employees’ early experiences and provide advice without it taking too much time. It needs to be easy for them, simple, and personalized.

Second, it can help to provide managers with their own onboarding checklist. Whereas HR has a number of onboarding steps for a new employee (e.g., forms, benefits, etc.), each manager should have a clear set of manager onboarding steps that they should be striving to check off. For example, this might include having an early career direction conversation, setting preliminary goals, taking some time to informally get to know the employee, or simply having the new employee get exposed to the right people and learning activities. 

Third, the manager should be held accountable for onboarding success and failure. On some level, early employee retention and ultimately positive early tenure engagement should rest heavily on the manager’s shoulders. He/she should be evaluated on how successful they onboard new employees including whether they take extra steps to help the employee to adapt or go above and beyond to knock down potential obstacles that threaten a new employee’s experience (e.g., advocating for an employee about an exception to a policy).

There’s nothing more frustrating than filling a position that’s been open for a long time, only to have your manager drop the ball during the critical onboarding phase, leaving you right back where you started. But by giving your managers guidelines for successful onboarding, helping them build their own onboarding checklist, and by holding them accountable for onboarding success, you can very positively impact employee retention. 

The latest from our blog

Uncategorized

Transparency in the workplace: striking the right organizational balance

Discover the significance of transparency in the workplace. Learn its benefits, challenges, and effective strategies to create a...

Employee Engagement

Quiet cracking: The hidden strain on middle managers – and what HR can do about it

Quiet cracking is the silent unraveling of middle managers under the weight of compounding pressure from all sides.

Talent Optimization

What we taught viewers about the future of work on Advancements

On a recent episode of Advancements, PI had the chance to talk about what’s actually changing inside organizations,...

Behavioral Assessments

Decoding relationships at work with PI

I partnered with The Predictive Index to talk about how their Behavioral Assessment helped me better understand myself...

Hiring

Applicant vs candidate: understanding the differences and hiring best practices

Understand the difference between applicants and candidates, as well as best practices for how to treat each during...

Hiring

Enhancing the candidate experience: proven strategies for recruitment success

With applicant tracking systems and behavioral insights, your organization can improve candidate experience and promote a people-first hiring...

Behavioral Assessments

What is content validity?

Learn about content validity, its types, and why it matters for HR. Discover best practices for selecting scientifically...

Talent Optimization

Seeing through perception bias: Get the infographic.

The perception gap manifests in many ways. HR can help mitigate perception bias through the use of behavioral...

Employee Engagement

Misunderstood at work is the new burnout: Nearly half of workers say their boss doesn’t truly get them.

Our 2025 survey revealed a perception gap: Nearly half of employees believe their boss only somewhat or rarely...

Back to top
Copy link