How does The Predictive Index test work?

How does The Predictive Index test work? Learn how to use PI’s cognitive and behavioral assessments for hiring and beyond.


How does The Predictive Index test work?

Perhaps you need to take the PI Behavioral Assessment™ and the PI Cognitive Assessment™ as part of the job search. Or maybe your company is considering purchasing PI to improve business outcomes. Either way, you want to know: What is The Predictive Index test? And how does PI work?

What is The Predictive Index test?

First of all, there are no PI “tests.” The word test implies you can pass or fail, and that’s not the case with any of PI’s workplace assessments. The Predictive Index measures behavioral drives (Dominance, Extraversion, Patience, and Formality) as well as cognitive ability. 

PI assessments help business leaders:

  • Understand the needs of a specific role, team, project, or business strategy
  • Collect candidate or employee “people data”  
  • Use that data to make more informed—and more objective—decisions

These decisions include who to hire, how to manage, when to add a new executive, and more.

How you might use PI to make a hiring decision

You’re a health care organization and you need to hire a registered nurse. Obviously there will be some basic education and skill requirements that must be met. But beyond that, a resume doesn’t tell you much about a person’s personality traits or learning speed. To predict whether someone’s a good fit for the RN role, you’d need to answer questions like:

  • Will the candidate be assertive enough to speak up for patient safety? 
  • Is the person wired to enjoy working with and through others?
  • Can they keep up with all the new technology, procedures, and treatments? 

Every business runs on decisions about people. Who to hire. How to give someone hard feedback. Which team should take on a new strategy. Each of those decisions rests on a read of how people will behave, and most organizations still make that read from memory and instinct.

Behavioral intelligence platforms change that. They capture signals about how people think, work, buy, and engage, and turn them into guidance someone can act on. The category is wide, and the platforms in it differ on the question that matters most: whether the insight is there when the decision is being made.

This guide covers 15 behavioral intelligence platforms across four areas, explains how each one works, and shows when its insight arrives. It also makes our point of view plain, because we have one.

A note on objectivity: The Predictive Index publishes this guide and appears in it. We list PI first and say why. Every other platform is described on its own strengths, based on public information.

Quick Answer: What Is a Behavioral Intelligence Platform?
A behavioral intelligence platform connects what is known about people, such as how they are wired, how they work, or how they buy, with the situation in front of you, and suggests what to do next. The most useful ones deliver that insight at the moment of decision, whether the decision is a single conversation or a company-wide plan.

Behavioral Intelligence Has to Meet the Moment

Behavioral data describes tendencies. It becomes behavioral intelligence at the point someone does something differently because of it. That point is almost always a specific moment, with specific people, under real time pressure.

We think the best behavioral intelligence is timely, and adapts to the moment it is needed in. That applies at two very different scales:

  • Everyday relationships at work. A first 1:1 with a new report. Feedback that has to land well. Two teammates who keep clashing over pace. A new hire who has not asked for help once. Each moment calls for different advice depending on who is in the room.
  • Business strategy. Reorganizing teams around a new goal. Hiring for a role where priorities shift constantly. Leading people through an organizational change. The same behavioral data that shapes a conversation should shape the plan.

Plenty of good behavioral insight arrives late: a profile that sits in a drawer after hiring, an annual survey, a dashboard reviewed once a quarter. So for every platform below, we asked two questions. When does the insight arrive? And does it adapt to the specific people and situation involved?

15 Behavioral Intelligence Platforms Compared

#PlatformBehavioral data it readsWhen the insight arrivesBest for
1The Predictive IndexValidated behavioral assessments and situational awareness.Before the hire, before the conversation, and when a role or team changesHiring, managing, team strategy, applied behavioral AI
2Hogan AssessmentsPersonality, derailers, and valuesAt selection and development milestones, usually through a certified practitionerExecutive selection and leadership development
3CrystalDISC personality, assessed or predicted from public profilesBefore a conversation, when someone opens a LinkedIn profileLearning how to communicate with a specific person
4CloverleafResults from many assessments, combinedDay to day, as coaching tips in the tools teams already useTeam coaching for organizations that use several assessments
5Phenom (with Plum)Psychometric assessments plus candidate activityDuring application and matching, and later in onboarding and internal mobilityHigh-volume talent acquisition with assessments built in
6HarverGame-based, personality, cognitive, and situational assessmentsDuring screening, before interviewsHigh-volume hiring
7VisierHR, payroll, and recruiting system dataWhen leaders ask workforce questions or run planning cyclesWorkforce analytics and planning
8Culture AmpEngagement surveys and performance feedbackAfter each survey or review cycle, with an AI coach for managers in betweenEngagement and performance programs
9PerceptyxEmployee listening across surveys and other channelsAfter surveys and through ongoing listening, with nudges to managersEnterprise employee listening
10Microsoft Viva InsightsMicrosoft 365 collaboration patternsIn personal and leader views inside Microsoft 365Meeting load, focus time, and collaboration habits
11GongSales calls, emails, and deal activityAfter calls and across the deal cycleSales coaching and forecasting
12Humantic AIBuyer personality predicted from public dataBefore outreach and sales meetingsPersonalizing outreach to buyers
13MedalliaCustomer and employee feedback and interaction signalsAs feedback arrives, with alerts to the teams who can actEnterprise customer experience programs
14FullstoryWeb and mobile sessions, clicks, and frustration signalsWhen teams review sessions, and in real time when signals are sent to other toolsFinding friction in digital experiences
15MixpanelProduct events, user journeys, and session replaysWhen teams run analyses, and through automated AI monitoringProduct analytics

How We Built This List

  • What qualifies: the platform captures behavioral data, meaning signals about how people think, act, work, buy, or engage, and turns it into guidance or decisions. General reporting and business intelligence tools are not included.
  • Order: PI is listed first because it is our platform and the clearest example of our point of view. The rest are grouped by the kind of behavior they read, in no particular order within each group.
  • What we looked at: the source of the behavioral data and the science behind it, when the insight reaches the people who act on it, and whether it adapts to specific people and situations.
  • Sources: each company’s own website and announcements, plus business directories where a company does not publish its headquarters. Headquarters, founding years, and ownership reflect public information as of November 2026.
  • Updates: platforms in this space change hands often. Plum, for example, became part of Phenom in 2026. We plan to review this list twice a year.

People and Talent Platforms

These platforms read who a person is: how they are wired, how they think, and how they are likely to work. They inform hiring, development, and the everyday relationships between managers and their people.

1. The Predictive Index

Headquarters: Westwood, MA · Founded: 1955 · Best for: Hiring, managing, and team strategy · Website

The Predictive Index (PI) has studied what drives people at work for 70 years. The PI Behavioral Assessment measures four primary drives: dominance, extraversion, patience, and formality. The PI Cognitive Assessment measures a person’s capacity to learn, adapt, and grasp new concepts. More than 10,000 organizations use PI.

Everyday relationships. Obi by PI brings that behavioral data into the moment. An HR leader asks Obi about a person and a situation, such as a first 1:1, tough feedback, or two teammates who keep clashing, and gets a playbook tailored to the people involved, ready to hand to the manager. Obi runs on a private AI grounded in PI’s behavioral science and the organization’s own data, and it respects PI permissions.

Moments of change. When someone’s role changes, a five-minute self-concept check-in shows how that person believes the role is asking them to behave right now, next to how they are naturally wired. The manager starts the next conversation from what has changed instead of a guess.

Business strategy. PI Design compares a team’s behavioral makeup with the kind of work the team is pursuing, so leaders can see where a team is set up to deliver on a strategy and where it will need support. PI Hire defines the behaviors a role requires before the search starts.

When the insight arrives: Before the hire, before the conversation, and when a role or team changes. Behavioral data that is ready for a single conversation and for a strategy shift, and adapts to the specific people involved in each.

2. Hogan Assessments

Headquarters: Tulsa, OK · Founded: 1987 · Best for: Executive selection and leadership development · Website

Hogan measures everyday personality, the derailers that tend to show up under pressure, and core values and motives. It is a common choice for senior selection and leadership coaching, and results are typically interpreted by a certified practitioner.

When the insight arrives: At selection and development milestones, usually through a certified practitioner. Deep, well-researched insight, delivered at planned milestones rather than day to day.

3. Crystal

Headquarters: Nashville, TN · Founded: 2015 · Best for: Learning how to communicate with a specific person · Website

Crystal assigns DISC personality types from its own assessment or predicts them from public information such as LinkedIn profiles, then suggests how to communicate with each person. In 2026 it rebuilt its product around a personal AI coach, and it still offers a business plan and a LinkedIn browser extension.

When the insight arrives: Before a conversation, when someone opens a LinkedIn profile. Well timed for a single conversation. Predicted profiles help with communication and are not designed for hiring decisions.

4. Cloverleaf

Headquarters: Cincinnati, OH · Best for: Team coaching for organizations that use several assessments · Website

Cloverleaf brings together results from more than a dozen assessments, including DISC, Enneagram, and CliftonStrengths, and turns them into short coaching tips delivered through tools such as Slack, Microsoft Teams, Gmail, Google Calendar, and Workday.

When the insight arrives: Day to day, as coaching tips in the tools teams already use. Built around everyday moments, with the depth of insight depending on which assessments an organization feeds it.

5. Phenom (with Plum)

Headquarters: Ambler, PA · Founded: 2010 · Best for: High-volume talent acquisition with assessments built in · Website

Phenom runs career sites, candidate engagement, and recruiting workflows for large employers. In 2026 it acquired two assessment companies: Be Applied in February, for cognitive and situational judgment tests, and Plum in April, whose assessments measure personality, social intelligence, and problem-solving. Phenom says it will carry that data into onboarding, career pathing, and manager coaching.

When the insight arrives: During application and matching, and later in onboarding and internal mobility. Strongest at the top of the hiring funnel, and extending the same assessment data past the offer.

6. Harver

Headquarters: Amsterdam, Netherlands · Founded: 2015 · Best for: High-volume hiring · Website

Harver combines game-based assessments (from pymetrics, now part of Harver), personality and cognitive tests, situational judgment tests, and reference checks in one hiring flow. It is built for employers that screen large numbers of applicants for hourly and entry-level roles. In September 2026 it acquired Symphony Talent, adding recruitment marketing.

When the insight arrives: During screening, before interviews. Built mainly for the screening decision, at very large scale.

Workforce and Organization Platforms

These platforms read how the organization is working: who is leaving, how people feel, and how collaboration actually happens. They inform planning and organization-wide decisions.

7. Visier

Headquarters: Vancouver, BC, Canada · Founded: 2010 · Best for: Workforce analytics and planning · Website

Visier connects data from HR, payroll, and recruiting systems and answers workforce questions such as who is likely to leave, where pay is out of line, and how headcount is changing.

When the insight arrives: When leaders ask workforce questions or run planning cycles. Shows patterns in what people do across the organization. Pairs well with tools that explain why.

8. Culture Amp

Headquarters: Melbourne, Australia · Founded: 2009 · Best for: Engagement and performance programs · Website

Culture Amp runs engagement surveys, performance reviews, and development programs, with benchmarks drawn from its customer base. HR teams use it to track how employees feel about their work and to act on the results. In November 2026 it announced Enso, an AI people partner for managers, with North American availability planned for early 2027.

When the insight arrives: After each survey or review cycle, with an AI coach for managers in between. A reliable read on sentiment from survey and review cycles, now reaching toward the moments in between.

9. Perceptyx

Headquarters: Temecula, CA · Founded: 2003 · Best for: Enterprise employee listening · Website

Perceptyx gathers employee feedback through surveys, lifecycle check-ins, and continuous listening, then points leaders to the groups and issues that need attention. Its acquisitions of Humu and Cultivate added behavioral nudges for managers.

When the insight arrives: After surveys and through ongoing listening, with nudges to managers. Moving from periodic surveys toward more timely nudges, with insight drawn mostly from aggregate feedback.

10. Microsoft Viva Insights

Headquarters: Redmond, WA · Best for: Meeting load, focus time, and collaboration habits · Website

Viva Insights analyzes collaboration data from Microsoft 365, such as meetings, email, and chat, to show how work actually happens. Leaders use it to spot meeting overload, after-hours work, and silos between teams, and increasingly to measure Copilot adoption.

When the insight arrives: In personal and leader views inside Microsoft 365. Insight from how people spend their time, which says a lot about workload and little about how individuals are wired.

Buyer and Revenue Platforms

These platforms read how buyers and sellers behave, so revenue teams can tailor outreach and coach on real conversations.

11. Gong

Headquarters: San Francisco, CA · Founded: 2015 · Best for: Sales coaching and forecasting · Website

Gong records and analyzes customer conversations and deal activity, then surfaces patterns linked to won and lost deals. Sales leaders use it to coach reps on real calls and to forecast with more confidence.

When the insight arrives: After calls and across the deal cycle. Insight drawn from what was actually said, available soon after each conversation.

12. Humantic AI

Headquarters: Palo Alto, CA · Best for: Personalizing outreach to buyers · Website

Humantic AI predicts a buyer’s DISC personality from public profiles and other written signals, then suggests how to tailor outreach, meetings, and follow-ups. It positions itself as buyer intelligence for sales teams.

When the insight arrives: Before outreach and sales meetings. Timed for the sales moment. Predicted profiles suit outreach, not people decisions inside the business.

Customer and Digital Experience Platforms

These platforms read how customers use a product or website, and where they struggle. They inform product and experience decisions.

13. Medallia

Headquarters: Tysons, VA and Pleasanton, CA · Founded: 2001 · Best for: Enterprise customer experience programs · Website

Medallia collects feedback and experience signals from surveys, contact centers, digital channels, and social media, then routes insights to the teams that can act on them.

When the insight arrives: As feedback arrives, with alerts to the teams who can act. Fast at surfacing what customers are experiencing, at the level of journeys and segments.

14. Fullstory

Headquarters: Atlanta, GA · Founded: 2014 · Best for: Finding friction in digital experiences · Website

Fullstory captures how people move through websites and apps, including session replay, frustration signals such as rage clicks, and drop-off points. Product and digital teams use it to see where users struggle and to check whether fixes worked, and its AI agents can flag friction and anomalies automatically.

When the insight arrives: When teams review sessions, and in real time when signals are sent to other tools. Detailed data on digital behavior. Most analysis happens after the session, though signals can also trigger actions in real time.

15. Mixpanel

Headquarters: San Francisco, CA · Founded: 2009 · Best for: Product analytics · Website

Mixpanel tracks events inside a product and shows funnels, retention, and cohorts. Product teams use it to understand which behaviors lead users to stay and which features go unused. It has added session replay and heatmaps, and in 2026 launched Mixpanel AI to surface issues automatically.

When the insight arrives: When teams run analyses, and through automated AI monitoring. Precise on what users did inside a product. Session replay and AI monitoring help explain why.

How to Choose a Behavioral Intelligence Platform

  • Start with the moment. Name the decision you want to improve, such as a hire, a manager conversation, a team redesign, a deal, or a product change. Then look for the platform whose insight shows up at that moment.
  • Check the science. Ask how the behavioral model was built and validated, and whether the vendor publishes its research. Profiles predicted from public data can help with outreach, and they are not a substitute for a validated assessment when the decision is about a person’s job.
  • Test for adaptation. Ask for the same scenario, such as delivering difficult feedback, for two very different people. If the guidance comes back the same, it is general advice, not behavioral intelligence.
  • Ask about privacy and permissions. Behavioral data is personal. Confirm who can see what, how data is stored and used, and whether people can see their own results.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Behavioral Intelligence?

Behavioral intelligence is knowing what drives people and acting on it in the moments that matter. It connects three things: what is known about a person, what the situation requires, and an approach that is likely to work.

How Is Behavioral Intelligence Different From Behavioral Analytics?

Behavioral analytics describes what people did, such as clicks, sessions, or survey scores. Behavioral intelligence connects behavioral insight to a specific situation and suggests what to do next. Many organizations use both.

Is Behavioral Intelligence the Same as Emotional Intelligence?

They are related. Emotional intelligence is about recognizing, understanding, and managing emotions. Behavioral intelligence brings insight into how people tend to work into a specific situation. A good manager draws on both.

Does Behavioral Intelligence Require AI?

No. Behavioral intelligence is a skill people can build through training and experience. AI makes it available in the moment, rather than only at a training session or when someone remembers to open a report.

Can Behavioral Data Be Used Fairly in Hiring?

Yes, when the assessment is validated for workplace use, applied consistently to every candidate, and used as one input alongside interviews and experience. Ask any vendor for its validation and adverse impact research.

What Is Obi by PI?

Obi by The Predictive Index delivers behavioral intelligence for moments that matter. HR leaders use Obi to prepare guidance for conversations such as first 1:1s, performance reviews, tough feedback, and organizational shifts, tailored to the specific people involved.

Personality assessments are more popular in hiring than ever, with over three-quarters of employers using personality and skills tests as a standard part of their vetting processes. A flood of AI-polished resumes has made it harder to evaluate candidates on paper, and more organizations are turning to assessments to get beyond the surface.

That instinct is right. But the formats gaining the most traction right now carry a design flaw that undermines the very thing they’re supposed to measure — and most hiring teams don’t realize they’re collecting noisier data because of it.

The issue comes down to how personality assessments are structured. Many of the most widely adopted tools on the market today use a forced-choice format, which requires candidates to compare a set of statements and identify which one is most like them and which is least. However, when candidates are spending several minutes parsing subtle semantic differences between options, they’re often problem-solving instead of self-reporting. To be clear, this is a question about personality measurement specifically. Cognitive ability tests work differently — they have right and wrong answers, so comparing options is the point.

Assessment design is a science decision, but it’s also a people decision. The format you choose shapes the quality of data you collect, the experience candidates have, and what your hiring process signals about your culture. There’s a better approach, and the reliability data backs it up.

Forced choice has become the dominant format in personality assessment because it feels rigorous. Asking candidates to weigh four statements against each other and identify which is most and least like them seems like it would produce more deliberate, considered responses. McKinsey uses a version of this format. So do many of the assessment providers that have seen the sharpest growth in adoption over the past few years.

But the cognitive load that format creates is a major problem. A candidate working through a forced-choice item isn’t simply describing themselves. They’re simultaneously running a comparison exercise, often between statements that are similar enough that the differences are genuinely subtle. That takes time and mental effort, and it compounds across an assessment.

By the end, you’re measuring how well they perform under cognitive strain rather than their self-concept. There’s nothing wrong with measuring cognitive ability — it’s a legitimate and useful predictor of job performance. But it belongs in a cognitive assessment, where the questions are designed for it and scored against right answers. When a behavioral assessment measures it by accident, you don’t get a bonus data point. You get a muddier read on the thing you were actually trying to measure.

That’s a design problem. A well-constructed assessment should reduce friction between a candidate and their honest self-perception. The data quality you get from someone who is fatigued or second-guessing their way through an item set is meaningfully lower than what you get from someone moving through a natural, intuitive experience. That gap will show up in your hiring decisions.

Free choice captures authentic self-perception

Our Behavioral Assessment takes a fundamentally different approach. Rather than forcing comparisons between statements, candidates simply select the adjectives that apply to them — as many or as few that feel accurate. When candidates feel a sense of autonomy in how they’re being asked to describe themselves, they engage honestly. Face validity — the degree to which an assessment feels relevant and fair to the person taking it — directly influences the quality of responses you get. A candidate who trusts the process is a candidate who gives you usable data.

That also has practical implications for who completes the assessment at all. Candidates who encounter a cumbersome, time-consuming format early in the hiring process are more likely to abandon it or disengage quietly and rush through. Either outcome costs you information. A format that respects how people naturally think about themselves produces better results more often than forced choice.

The free-choice format also removes the pressure to reconcile ambiguous options. When there’s no forced comparison, there’s no overthinking. What you’re left with is a cleaner read on how someone genuinely perceives their own behavioral tendencies, exactly what a personality assessment is supposed to deliver.

Longer doesn’t mean more reliable

There’s a reasonable assumption that a longer, more complex assessment produces more thorough results. More questions, more data, better picture. In practice, that logic doesn’t hold up.

Our Behavioral Assessment takes about six minutes to complete. Every five years, we put it through EFPA recertification, a process where independent auditors with PhDs in I/O psychology review our methodology and actively look for weaknesses in it.

As part of that process, we conduct test-retest reliability studies that track the same individuals across multiple time points, up to four years apart. Test-retest reliability measures how consistently a person gets the same result over time; the closer the score is to 1, the more stable the assessment. The values we see range from .2 to .5, which is considered high for multi-year measurement, where some natural drift in self-perception is expected. In some cases, these values even surpass those reported for the Big Five, one of the most extensively studied personality frameworks in the field.

That kind of stability over time is what makes an assessment defensible to use in hiring. A longer, more complex format doesn’t produce it. Thoughtful design does.

Assessment design is a people decision

Most organizations choose an assessment the same way they choose any HR vendor: by evaluating features, checking validation claims and moving on. What often gets skipped is understanding what the experience communicates to the people taking it. Every candidate who completes your assessment is forming an impression of your organization before they’ve spoken to a single person on your team.

How candidates experience an assessment shapes how honestly they engage with it. That has downstream effects on employer brand, offer acceptance and the quality of the talent pool you attract over time. Candidates talk. A hiring process that feels fair and respectful of their time reflects well on your organization. One that feels burdensome does the opposite.

The best assessment programs are built around a clear understanding of what you’re trying to learn about candidates and what experience you want them to have while you’re learning it. Format, length and design aren’t secondary considerations — they determine whether the data you collect actually reflects the people behind it. An assessment that candidates trust produces results you can trust. Want to see how our Behavioral Assessment compares? Explore our assessments.

A well-intentioned manager pulls up a blank document, glances at the meeting invite and opens with a question that would work for anyone — “how’s everything going?” — which means it works perfectly for no one. Three floors up, another manager with a VP title and a team of 12 is presenting an AI-generated deck they skimmed five minutes before the meeting started.

This is the default mode for managers at every level who care about their people but are trying to lead them without the context to do it well.

Our Motivation at Work Survey shows 78% of employees start motivated, but 72% lose that drive. Only 10% report that meetings with their manager are always productive. When communication dries up, employees look elsewhere for guidance, often turning to AI tools instead of their bosses.

The gap between a struggling team and a thriving one usually comes down to context. When managers walk into conversations already knowing what drives each team member, how they process feedback and what they need to grow, everything changes. That information exists; most managers just haven’t been given it.

Why do managers across every industry struggle with similar communication gaps?

Managers guessing at what their people need isn’t unique to your organization. This breakdown shows up inside well-run companies with well-intentioned leaders across every industry and growth stage.

It just looks a little different depending on where you sit:

  • The Startup Manager: They promoted their top performer, handed them four direct reports and never had a real conversation about what leading people actually requires. The new manager does what feels natural. i.e., they keep doing the heavy lifting themselves and hope the team figures out the rest.
  • The Enterprise Director: They run ten 1:1s a week using a rigid template HR built three years ago. Every conversation starts the same way, and every employee gets the same questions. The agenda was designed to scale, not to connect.
  • The Time-Crunched Executive: They ask AI to build a deck for an all-hands meeting, skim the title slide five minutes before and spend an hour presenting high-level content they can’t speak to with any real depth.
  • The Well-Meaning Boss: They give feedback the way they want to receive it, set expectations the way they prefer and try to motivate their team using what drives them personally. Their intent isn’t to come off as careless; their own experience is simply the only reference point they have.

There’s no universal playbook because there’s no universal employee. When managers rely on guesswork, old templates or generic AI prompts to bridge the gap, it points to a clear structural gap that most organizations just haven’t filled yet.

What do managers actually gain when they have better information?

Managers who have the right data can shift their typical approach instantly. They can be the manager who:

  • Sends a quick note the night before because they know their direct report processes written feedback best. Now, the conversation can dive right into solutions instead of catching them off guard.
  • Stops checking in daily because they understand their employee is driven by autonomy, choosing instead to ask where the employee wants to take the project next.
  • Gives a quieter team member space to think because they realize that silence isn’t disengagement, just a need for processing time.

The difference between a good manager and a great one is what they know when walking into the room. When you scale those small, intentional shifts across an entire team, the day-to-day dynamic completely transforms.

Managers with the right information can spot nuances much quicker than managers who have to rely on guesswork. As AI takes on more of the administrative layer of work — flattening people into outputs and activity metrics — the manager relationship is one of the few places where someone still has to actually see the individual. Plenty of tools can draft a perfect team meeting deck in seconds, but most can’t tell you which employees are doing well, struggling or at risk of leaving the company.

What changes when managers stop guessing?

The friction in the modern workplace — burnout, overreliance on quick AI fixes and slipping motivation — is a structural failure. That executive deck built in five minutes or the 1:1 agenda pulled from an old template are symptoms of the same core problem. When managers outsource their preparation to AI tools they haven’t interrogated, they create distance between themselves and their teams at exactly the moments that matter most. The template stays intact, but the connection dies.

At the organizational level, this guesswork compounds into a massive hidden cost. Leaders are forced to make critical calls about who is ready, who is struggling and who is about to leave based on incomplete information. Gut feel and tenure become the proxies for readiness. High-potential employees go unrecognized, and disengagement sets in before anyone sees it coming.

We need to stop making managers guess. Giving leaders access to behavioral data completely rewrites this dynamic. In fact, we found that managers who use behavioral science in their daily communication are 49% more likely to rate their direct reports as ready for promotion. The difference between a good manager and a great one is simply what they know when walking into the room.

When an organization replaces guesswork with actual insight, the daily experience of work shifts. Teams stop turning to AI tools for guidance or using them to bypass their leaders. Instead, they rely on a human relationship that offers real clarity and connection. A manager walks into every conversation already knowing what drives the person across from them, how to frame feedback and where the friction is likely to come from before it does.

Effective leadership requires putting this baseline information into the right hands. The insight exists and must be given to those who shape employees’ careers every day.

Want to take the guesswork out of your team’s day-to-day? Try our behavioral assessment to see exactly what drives your people and how to help them succeed.

Over 75% of employers use skills tests during hiring, and about 80% of the Fortune 500 use personality assessments. By the time a new hire walks in the door, organizations already have rich behavioral data on who that person is and how they work best.

Then that data gets shelved — right as it becomes valuable.

Our Motivation at Work survey finds employee motivation is strong at the outset, with 78% of employees starting their current role motivated. But it fades fast: Only 16% told us their work feels meaningful. That’s not a coincidence. When behavioral data stops being used in the hiring decision, personalized management goes by the wayside.

Organizations have missed out on key data that could improve motivation and productivity. The fix requires treating behavioral data as a continuous input, embedded into how managers communicate, develop and support their people from day one.

Management strategies are getting generic

When we asked employees what would most improve their motivation, they pointed to clearer priorities, more recognition, fewer meetings and more autonomy — all responsibilities that managers control. Instead, most leaders default to generic, one-size-fits-all approaches rather than individualized ones.

When leaders ignore key behavioral context, employees feel unseen and unmotivated, and leaders unintentionally drive burnout. One recent Harvard Business Review study found that managers are more likely to overburden their most motivated employees. Because they appear enthusiastic, capable and willing, they get assigned more extraneous tasks. And it’s making them like their jobs less.

The assumption behind this is flawed twice over: that motivated employees will welcome any work thrown at them, and that loving a job protects against burnout. Neither is true. In reality, organizations are giving their best people a reason to disengage, which is costing the world economy an estimated $10 trillion in lost productivity.

Part of the problem is that managers are often leading without any individualized context for what actually motivates, drains or supports each employee. Even organizations that collect behavioral insights during hiring rarely continue using them once someone joins the team.

Abandoning behavioral data post-hire only compounds this disengagement crisis. It’s time organizations start using it for what it’s designed to do.

What behavioral data is actually designed for

Most companies treat behavioral assessments and data as a hiring tool when their purpose achieves much more.

Every person at work is driven by something — a need for autonomy, structure, speed, connection or precision. Those drives aren’t situational. They shape how someone processes information, responds to feedback, collaborates under pressure and receives recognition. They’re present on day one and every day after. A behavioral profile captures all of it.

That’s the intelligence organizations are sitting on. When it stays in the applicant tracking system, managers are left leading without the very context that predicted success in the first place. They default to generic communication, one-size-fits-all recognition and gut-feel feedback, none of which accounts for what actually drives the person in front of them.

The result is friction that compounds quietly in the form of missed signals, misread behaviors and employees who feel like they’re managed by policy rather than known as people. Engagement doesn’t crater overnight. It erodes in the gap between what behavioral data could tell a manager and what that manager actually knows.

That data should still be working post-hire, shaping how managers communicate, give feedback and motivate their teams every single day.

What using behavioral data post-hire looks like

Behavioral data has an important role in daily management. Acting on it helps with:

  • Guiding cross-functional relationships. Not everyone processes conflict, feedback or pressure the same way. When managers understand the behavioral drives of people across teams, they can adjust how they communicate, which reduces friction before it starts and builds the kind of trust that makes collaboration sustainable.
  • Managing more effectively. Generic feedback lands differently depending on who’s receiving it. Behavioral drives tell managers how each person prefers to be recognized, directed and challenged, so the guidance they give actually sticks rather than getting filtered out or misread.
  • Referencing profiles within the flow of work. The value of behavioral data compounds in small moments: a 1:1 agenda, a tense team meeting, a conversation that could go sideways. Having that context on hand means managers can show up prepared instead of reactive.
  • Personalizing development. Growth paths built on generic competency benchmarks rarely reflect how a person actually operates. Behavioral data surfaces what energizes each employee and where they’re most likely to thrive, making development conversations more honest and more useful for both sides.

Manage the distinctive quality in each individual, and motivation and engagement will become a byproduct.

What changes when you use behavioral data

When behavioral data informs the day-to-day, manager relationships become more effective. Communication gets cleaner. And employees managed as unique contributors leave work feeling understood and supported.

Organizations that replace guesswork with data-backed insight stop chasing engagement and start producing it. Higher retention, stronger team performance and more consistent leadership will follow. And with AI surfacing the right insights at the right moment, that’s no longer a practice that requires managers to remember every profile or dig through a report. It becomes part of how they already work.

Put your behavioral data to work with AI-powered insights that give managers a science-backed foundation for understanding what drives each person and how to act on it in real time.

Know your people before the next reorg, not after

Reorgs used to be an event. Now they are a rhythm. Each new manager, merged team, or role rebuilt around AI is a bet on how specific people will work together, and most companies place it with an org chart and a job title, as if the people in the boxes were interchangeable. They aren’t. Bain found 88% of leaders expect their reorg to hit its goals, but only 36% of employees agree. In this Perspectives session, Matt Poepsel, PhD and our panel show how HR can use behavioral intelligence to read the people behind the boxes, advise leaders before the move, and stand behind that advice.

Join us to:

  • See where your org chart’s assumptions about people are weakest.
  • Start with what the work needs, then build the team around it.
  • Pair managers and teams by how each person leads, not by title or tenure.
  • Find the real reason a team that looks right on paper isn’t working.
  • Keep your read on people current as reorgs come faster.

Credits

Bonus for our live attendees… tune in for 1 HRCI and 1 SHRM credit!

Panelists – TBA!

Matt Poepsel, PhD
Matt Poepsel, PhD
he/him
Host

In the rush to simply deploy more tools, increase productivity and move faster, organizations have left behind their most valuable competitive differentiator: their people. 

Those AI tools no longer set you apart. Your competitors have access to many of the same technologies. The same automation. The same efficiency gains. 

The organizations that actually win in an AI-saturated market won’t have better tools or more output. They’ll have better insight into their people — and they’ll use behavioral intelligence to engage, develop and align their workforce in ways competitors can’t replicate.

How AI is making people decisions worse

Many organizations find themselves having smarter tools than ever before but still struggling with engagement, communication and change management.

Part of the issue is that many organizations have deployed AI on top of a workforce that’s already disengaging. Gallup’s State of the Global Workforce report found that engagement has dropped to 20% globally. HR leaders report higher burnout rates, with a third of employees silently feeling depleted and checked out. And our own Motivation at Work survey finds that only 16% of employees find their work regularly meaningful.

These are problems that no amount of AI can fix. 

Ask AI for advice on a colleague without behavioral context, and it’ll give you recommendations that sound reasonable and miss the point entirely. Feed it a job description without behavioral requirements, and it’ll help you make the wrong hire — confidently.

Don’t get me wrong. AI is absolutely creating value by summarizing meetings, identifying patterns, forecasting and removing administrative load. But when it comes to making people decisions, it lacks the knowledge to provide the right expertise. 

It doesn’t know your teammates’ motivations, each employee’s communication style or your team’s dynamics. So when managers or leaders rely on AI for guidance in those areas without understanding the people behind them, they manage on assumptions, not intelligence. 

The initial output from AI may feel productive. But the reality is only more slop, more disengagement and more conflict. What you need is behavioral intelligence. 

Why behavioral intelligence matters more in an AI era

Behavioral intelligence provides what no AI tool can: genuine insight into how your people think, communicate, make decisions and respond to change.

When leaders have that foundation, they move away from managing on hit-or-miss assumptions and instead manage on science-backed awareness of who their people are and what they actually need. That changes how leadership builds teams, shares feedback, resolves conflict and guides employees through change.

This matters more, not less, as AI accelerates the pace of change. In part, because your employees will need different things as you add AI tools. When we asked workers what they need in the face of AI adoption, the responses varied: 

  • 68% want more training opportunities
  • 61% want clear communication from leadership
  • 58% want job reassurance
  • 44% want a defined career growth path
  • 40% want involvement in AI decision-making
  • 29% want mentorship or coaching

The five-generation workforce makes managing these differences both harder and more urgent as Gen Z, millennials, Gen X and boomers all work side by side, each with different expectations around communication, feedback, autonomy and technology. Without a behavioral framework, managing across that range becomes guesswork. With one, it becomes a genuine competitive advantage.

How leaders can keep people at the center of their AI transformation

The path forward isn’t complicated. It starts with three decisions:

  • Manage with behavioral insight. Use behavioral assessments to discover your employees’ natural fit, how they complement one another and where friction may arise. This context makes coaching more effective, teams better aligned and change possible regardless of the age range or skill level on your team.
  • Build behavioral context into AI inputs. AI tools can support managers, but only if they have the context to do so. Incorporate insights about team dynamics, communication styles and what motivates each employee into the AI tools you use. This way, your decisions about people will be based on data rather than guesswork.
  • Bring employees on the journey. Change lands differently depending on how people are wired. Communicate what’s shifting and why, acknowledge the fears and questions that come with it and recognize that different behavioral styles need different kinds of support to move forward. 

Behavioral intelligence is how you build your competitive advantage. PI’s tools give you a science-backed foundation to get started. Learn more about how to use PI’s platform to manage smarter and bring your people along on the AI journey.

Client Software Agreement

This agreement applies to our clients use of PI products, including the talent optimization software.

AI Terms Addendum

This addendum applies to our clients use of PI product features that incorporate AI models or tools.

Website Terms of Use

These terms apply to website visitors’ use of our website and online resources.

Assessment Taker Agreement

This agreement applies to individuals who take a PI assessment.

Assessment Taker Agreement

Background

The Predictive Index, LLC (“PI,” “we,” “our,” or “us”) is a cloud-based SaaS platform that provides our Clients with Talent Optimization software and other products and services (collectively, the “Software”).

Our clients are typically employers, partners, coaches, consultants and other organizations that contract with PI to use its Software (“Clients”). Clients or their agents typically then request or require individuals like you (“you” or “Assessment Taker”) to take the assessments provided through the Software (each an “Assessment”, collectively the “Assessments”).

This Assessment Taker Agreement (“Agreement”) contains the terms and conditions for accessing and taking our assessments, so if this Agreement doesn’t work for you, we’re sorry but you cannot take our assessments. By electronically acknowledging this document, you agree to this Agreement and the two linked documents listed at the end of this Agreement.

1. User’s Authorized Use and Restrictions

You make the following representations and warranties regarding your access to and taking of the Assessments:

  1. You will comply with all applicable laws and you acknowledge that PI is not responsible for advising you on compliance with any applicable Laws.
  2. By entering into this Agreement, you agree to also abide by our Website Terms of Use.
  3. You will not attempt to gain unauthorized access to the Software or related systems or networks or disrupt the integrity or performance of the Software or third party data contained therein.
  4. You will not allow access to or use of the Assessments to others. You will not allow someone to take the Assessments on your behalf.
  5. You will not use, modify, copy, or create derivative works based on the Assessments or PI’s other intellectual property, or any part, feature, function, or user interface thereof. PI shall own all derivative works. You will not use our Assessments or derive information from our Assessments for purposes of reselling, copying, distributing, posting, advertising or disclosing the content therein. For avoidance of doubt, you cannot use the Assessments for purposes of creating competitive projects or otherwise copying the information, such as screenshotting questions or results.
  6. You will not disassemble, reverse engineer, or decompile the Software or Assessments, or any part thereof, or otherwise access our Assessments to copy the ideas, functions, graphics, or other features or to build a competitive or “preparatory” product or service.
  7. You will not access the Assessments if you are a competitor or to monitor the availability, performance, or functionality or for any other benchmarking or competitive purposes.
  8. You acknowledge that our Assessments are not designed to comply with industry-specific regulations, including without limitation, HIPAA, GLBA, or FISMA. Therefore, you will not disclose, store or transmit any communications subject to these laws in or through the Software.
  9. You consent to PI’s use and disclosure of information you enter into the Assessment or otherwise provide to PI, including but not limited to disclosure to PI’s Clients, partners, for purposes of using AI tools and any and all other business purposes.

2. Data and Privacy

  1. Ownership and Representations. You have no right to ownership in the data entered into the Assessment or Software and have no expectation of privacy as to such information.
  2. Our Use of Your Data. You grant us ownership in all materials submitted by you in the process of accessing and taking the Assessment. We may monitor your access to and usage of the Assessments. Such usage information may be utilized by us and provided to the Client that requested you complete the Assessment (your potential or current employer) for business needs relating to our relationship with our Clients.
  3. Privacy Laws; EU/EEA Processing. If you are an individual user who is not taking an Assessment at the request of one of our Clients, for the purposes of privacy laws, PI is the data controller, “business” or equivalent and the “service processor” or equivalent. As such, PI determines the purposes for which and the means by which the data is collected. If you are an individual user located in the European Union or the European Economic Area, our legal basis for collecting and using your Personal Information will likely be (i) your consent (which you provide in this Agreement); (ii) your consent (by taking the Assessment); and/or (iii) performance of a contract. For more information on how we use your Personal Information if you are an individual user, please see our Privacy Policy.
  4. Security. PI has implemented and will maintain information security practices and safeguards as described in our Trust Center, which include physical, organizational, and technical measures designed to preserve the security, integrity, and confidentiality of the Software and to protect against information security threats. PI may update such security practices and safeguards from time to time, provided that any such update does not materially reduce the overall level of security or commitments as described therein.

3. PI Disclaimers

  1. We do not warrant that the Assessments or Software will perform in accordance with any specifications, documentation, or other standards, nor do we make any warranties as to the results obtained from the use of the Assessments or Software. We do not warrant the Software or Assessments will be available in an uninterrupted capacity, be error-free or bug-free, or provide complete or accurate data. We shall not be liable to you or any other entity or person for the inability to use the Assessments, or for any inaccuracies, errors, omissions, delays, computer viruses or other infirmity or corruption, damages, claims, liabilities, or losses, regardless of cause, in or arising from the use of our Assessments. We reserve the right to modify, change, update, or discontinue any aspect of the Assessments or Software at any time

    The Software may utilize artificial intelligence and you consent to the information you enter being used by artificial intelligence.

4. Indemnification, Liability And Confidentiality

  1. Indemnification. You will indemnify, defend and hold us harmless, at your expense, against any action or claim brought against PI (and our officers, directors, employees, agents, service providers and licensors) to the extent that such action is based upon or arises out of (a) your unauthorized or illegal use of the Assessments, (b) your noncompliance with or breach of this Agreement, or (c) all legal fees and costs should your use of the data result in infringements on our intellectual property. We will: (x) notify you in writing within thirty (30) days of our becoming aware of any such claim; (y) give you sole control of the defense or settlement of such a claim; and (z) provide you (at your expense) with any and all information and assistance reasonably requested by you to handle the defense or settlement of the claim. You shall not accept any settlement that (i) imposes an obligation on us; (ii) requires us to make an admission; or (iii) imposes liability not covered by these indemnifications or places restrictions on us without our prior written consent.
  2. Liability. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, PI’s maximum aggregate liability to you related in any way to or in connection with this Agreement, including your access to the Assessments, shall be limited to the lower of: (a) $250 and (b) the amount of estimated pro-rated fees actually paid by the Client procuring the Software for your use that would reasonably correlate to your individual use of the Software. TO THE EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE FOR ANY CONSEQUENTIAL, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, PUNITIVE OR ENHANCED DAMAGES, LOST PROFITS, REVENUES, OR DIMINUTION IN VALUE, ARISING OUT OF, RELATING TO, OR IN CONNECTION WITH ANY BREACH OF THIS AGREEMENT, REGARDLESS OF (A) WHETHER SUCH DAMAGES WERE FORESEEABLE, (B) WHETHER OR NOT ANY PARTY WAS ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES AND (C) THE LEGAL OR EQUITABLE THEORY (CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE) UPON WHICH THE CLAIM IS BASED.
  3. Confidentiality. “Confidential Information” means all information provided by PI (“Disclosing Party”) to you (“Receiving Party”) or made accessible to you by PI in connection with your access to the Assessments, whether orally or in writing that is designated as confidential or is, by its nature, deemed to be confidential. Confidential Information will include PI’s assessments and reports, the features and functionalities of the Assessments, the Software, technical data, and the terms of your use. Confidential Information does not include any information that (i) is or becomes generally known to the public without breach of any obligation owed to the Disclosing Party or (ii) was known to the Receiving Party before receipt from the Disclosing Party. The Receiving Party will: (i) protect the confidentiality of the Confidential Information using the same degree of care that it uses with its own confidential information of similar nature, but with no less than commercially reasonable care, (ii) not use any Confidential Information for any purpose outside the scope of this Agreement, (iii) not disclose Confidential Information to any third party (except our third party service providers), and (iv) limit access to Confidential Information to its employees, contractors, advisors and agents. You agree not to disclose PI’s Confidential Information.

5 Other Important Stuff

  1. Reservation Of Rights. Subject to the limited rights expressly granted hereunder, we reserve all right, title and interest in and to the Software, including all related intellectual property rights, and you shall not make a claim to the contrary. For the avoidance of doubt, this reservation of rights specifically includes, without limitation, the Assessments and any reports generated via the Software distributed to you. You acknowledge that you have not been granted any rights, except as expressly provided herein, and that misappropriation or unauthorized disclosure or use of the Assessments, Software, or intellectual property by you or others would cause irreparable harm in a manner for which damages would not be an adequate remedy, and therefore, we are entitled to seek injunctive or equitable relief to restrain any actual or threatened breach of the Agreement and we are further entitled to immediately suspend access to your account(s).
  2. Governing Law. The State of Delaware’s laws, except for conflict of laws rules, will apply to any dispute related to this Agreement.
  3. Arbitration. The parties agree than PI’s actions other than to enforce the restrictions in this Agreement (“Excluded Claims”), all other disputes between You and PI, including PI’s affiliated entities, parent company, owners, directors, employees, workers and agents (“PI Parties”) must be filed in binding individual arbitration through Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Service (“JAMS”). The parties agree to file the Arbitration in Boston, Massachusetts or through the JAMS virtual division (https://www.jamsadr.com/online, conducting the arbitration in fully remotely). The parties agree to limit all written discovery to one thousand (1,000) pages of documents in the mediation.

    As you know, PI Parties are not your employer and do not make decisions regarding your employment or application for employment. If a claim based upon employment is brought, note this arbitration agreement would also cover employment claims, such as wage and hour claims, breach of contract, torts, violation of public policy, discrimination, harassment, and any other employment-related claim under any state or federal statutes or laws. For avoidance of doubt, claims covered by this arbitration provision include all claims, past, present and future. This arbitration provision also covers any and all claims that PI may have against you arising out of your use of the Assessments or PI’s Client’s use of the Software with respect to you except for Excluded Claims. This arbitration agreement is governed and enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act (“FAA”).

    You agree to give PI a demand concerning the dispute twenty (20) days before filing an arbitration action. The arbitration will be conducted by one neutral arbitrator as the exclusive remedy for such controversy, claim or dispute. The arbitrator shall issue a written decision stating the essential findings and conclusions on which the award is based, and shall have full authority to award all remedies that would be available in court. The parties agree to abide by any award issued by the arbitrator. The parties shall pay all arbitrator’s fees and any arbitration administrative expenses evenly. If you feel that you cannot afford to pay for the arbitration, you may submit a request to PI pay for the arbitration, which PI will have two weeks to respond to in writing (and may in its sole discretion grant or deny such request). Any judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrator may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. The arbitration agreement does not include any claim which by law is not subject to mandatory arbitration, including workers’ compensation, unemployment compensation benefits, and administrative charges for unfair labor practices brought before the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).

    New Jersey Users Only: New Jersey users may choose to file, but are not required to file, New Jersey Law Against Discrimination claims in arbitration and may opt to file such claims in court.

    Maryland Users Only: If the FAA does not apply, the agreement will be governed by Maryland Uniform Arbitration Act (MUAA) pursuant to Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 3-206.

    California Users. Nothing in this Agreement shall be interpreted to mean that you are precluded from filing complaints with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD). The class action waiver applies to any claim you bring as a private attorney general (“PAGA”) on your own behalf and not on behalf of others. You understand that, if you bring a PAGA action, your individual claims must be arbitrated prior to any state court action on behalf of others. Disputes California users have regarding the validity, enforceability or breach of the class action waiver may be resolved only by a civil court of competent jurisdiction. PI agrees to pay the costs of arbitration if your use was in connection with a Client’s employment or potential employment and you are in California.

    Users Outside of the United States. The arbitration provision will not apply to you if you reside in a jurisdiction where the provision is illegal.
  4. Entire Agreement. This Agreement, is the entire agreement between the parties regarding the subject matter herein, and supersedes all other representations, warranties, and agreements.
  5. Assignment. Neither party may assign any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement to anyone else, without the other party’s prior written consent. However, PI may assign this Agreement without the other party’s consent only in connection with a merger, acquisition, or by a sale of substantially all of its assets. The surviving entity in the transaction will be included in the definition of Predictive Index, LLC.
  6. Relationship of the Parties. PI is not your employer or principal. PI has no special obligations to you. PI is also not Client’s “agent” or a “joint employer” of any of Client’s employees and is not responsible for Client’s decisions regarding employees or applicants. Client is responsible for making all decisions, including employment decisions, independently from PI. You do not have a claim against PI if its Clients, partners or other subscribers decide not to hire you or to fire you, even if PI provides inaccurate, incorrect, or defective information.
  7. Waiver. Our failure to enforce our rights under this Agreement will not be construed as a waiver of those rights.
  8. Severability. If any provision of this Agreement is held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be contrary to law, the provision will be deemed null and void without any effect to the remaining provisions.
  9. Feedback. You may provide us with feedback concerning the Assessments or Software or you may provide us with other comments and suggestions for new products, features, or improvements (collectively, “Feedback”). You grant us an unrestricted, irrevocable right to use such Feedback. All Feedback you provide to us shall be provided on an “as is” basis with no warranty. For the sake of clarity, you are not obligated to provide us with any Feedback under this Agreement.

You also agree to the Website Terms of Use.

“Website Terms of Use” can be found here:

https://www.predictiveindex.com/terms/website-terms/

Last modified November 13, 2026.

Every week, another company announces an AI mandate. Use it for meeting notes. Use it to write job descriptions. Use it to move faster. The directive comes from the top, and then it trickles down through layers of managers and teams, each one interpreting it a little differently.

By the time it reaches employees, “use AI” means something different in every corner of the organization. That inconsistency is a major problem that has little to do with the technology itself. According to a recent KPMG report, the biggest barriers to AI adoption are slow organizational change management and a lack of role-specific use cases — not the tools themselves. And yet HR leaders are expected to bridge that distance with no shared definition of what good adoption actually looks like.

The organizations making real progress are defining what AI use looks like in practice by role, team and even expected behavior. That work falls to HR because adoption depends on people changing how they work, and that requires clear expectations, aligned managers and the psychological safety to experiment.

How vague direction becomes inconsistent execution

When a mandate lacks definition, managers fill in the blanks themselves. One team treats AI as a writing tool. Another uses it to automate reporting. A third hasn’t touched it at all because no one explained what “good” looks like for their function.

That variation compounds quickly. The further direction travels from the executive level, the more it gets filtered through each manager’s assumptions, priorities and comfort level with the technology. By the time it reaches individual contributors, expectations are uneven at best and contradictory at worst.

Employees notice, with some feeling the pressure to use AI for tasks it isn’t suited for, while others are left wondering whether their reluctance will be held against them. That ambiguity slows adoption significantly while creating real anxiety about job security and performance expectations.

What companies end up with is fragmented experimentation instead of intentional adoption. According to a report from Infosys and MIT Technology Review, 83% of business leaders say psychological safety has a measurable impact on the success of AI initiatives. Without it, employees won’t experiment, ask questions or admit when something isn’t working. That means the organization never builds the kind of honest feedback loop that actually improves adoption over time.

The pressure HR is absorbing

HR is caught managing tensions between leadership, who want productivity gains, and employees, who need time to adapt. Both are reasonable expectations, and HR is responsible for holding them at the same time without a clean solution in sight.

The slow pace of AI adoption is making HR’s position that much harder. When change moves faster than people are ready for, stress, disengagement and burnout risk rise quickly. These results then get attributed to performance issues rather than a rollout that outpaced its own support structure.

On the compliance side, HR also has to weigh the pressure to experiment against real risk exposure around data privacy, bias in AI-assisted decisions and regulatory requirements that’re still catching up to the technology. The pressure to move fast and the obligation to manage risk responsibly are pulling HR in opposite directions.

HR is expected to operationalize AI transformation without always having the authority to shape how it gets defined. The mandate comes from the top, while HR is left to deal with the consequences.

Operationalizing AI adoption

Companies must treat AI adoption as a communication problem and start treating it as an operational one if they want to see real progress. That means going beyond the mandate to define what AI-enabled work actually looks like in practice for everybody across the board.

Here are a few things that organizations can focus on now, and should do so consistently:

  • Role-specific expectations. Employees need to know what good AI use looks like in their function, not just in general. That means documenting concrete use cases by role and building those expectations into onboarding, performance conversations and team norms. Don’t leave it to each manager to figure out independently.
  • Manager alignment. Managers are the primary multiplier of adoption consistency. Calibrating them means giving them a shared definition of success, regular forums to surface what’s working and what isn’t and clear guidance on how to coach employees through the transition.
  • Psychological safety. Employees won’t experiment, admit mistakes or ask for help unless they feel safe doing so. Building that safety starts with leaders modeling the behavior they want to see by asking questions openly, acknowledging uncertainty and treating early AI experimentation as learning rather than performance.

AI adoption is ultimately a behavior change challenge. Organizations can build something durable and truly transformative when they treat it that way — and give HR the authority to lead it.

Ready to take on AI adoption at your organization? Learn how PI supports HR leaders through change.

According to PI’s 2026 AI and People Leadership Report, 67% of leaders say HR always or often coaches managers before a tough feedback conversation or conflict. HR support is the default experience for most managers heading into a hard conversation — at least according to leadership.

Managers, separately, were asked how often HR is available to help before more challenging conversations. Forty-three percent said HR is always available to help before a hard conversation, and 41% felt the support only shows up sometimes. Split almost evenly down the middle, reliable access to HR is closer to a coin flip than leaders realize.

When researchers asked managers what would help them most before a difficult conversation, only 11% chose time with HR. A general framework or checklist ranked highest, followed closely by coaching built around the specific employee they were about to sit down with.

HR can’t realistically provide individual coaching before every conversation happening across a company, so its greatest leverage comes from giving managers guidance they can apply the moment they need it. Managers want HR’s judgment built into something they can reach on their own, in the moment, without waiting on a person who can’t always be there.

What do managers need to feel more prepared and supported?

Managers need preparation built around the specific person they’re about to sit down with, not a generic approach applied the same way to everyone.

Our report also found that 42% of managers believe their last difficult conversation fell short because they knew what they wanted to say but struggled with how to say it. Another 26% couldn’t predict how the other person would respond, and 20% could plan the conversation but couldn’t adapt once it started going differently than expected.

None of this suggests HR is handing managers generic advice when they do ask for help. HR simply can’t sit in on every conversation happening across a company, and that limit shows up in how prepared a manager feels walking in. Without HR in the room, a manager is left guessing how a specific person will respond, and that uncertainty shapes the kind of guidance they end up relying on. A few common examples:

  • Rehearsing one version of a feedback conversation, then improvising entirely when an employee reacts with defensiveness instead of the calm response they’d prepared for.
  • Delivering the same framework to every employee, without adjusting for someone who needs more context before receiving criticism.
  • Avoiding a harder truth altogether, unsure whether direct feedback will land as constructive or combative with that particular person.

Seventy-six percent of managers say guidance tailored to the employee they’re meeting with would help them prepare. Insight into how a specific person communicates and receives feedback gives managers a clearer sense of how the conversation is likely to unfold before they’re in it.

How behavioral intelligence makes HR’s judgment available at scale

Behavioral guidance built around a specific employee has always required knowing the manager and the employee well. HR has historically been the most scalable source capable of offering something so tailored, which meant that kind of preparation was only available to the managers HR had the bandwidth to reach directly.

A general-purpose AI tool can still only offer a manager a generic script pulled from broad patterns, without any sense of how a particular employee is likely to respond. But AI paired with validated behavioral insight works differently by drawing on data that contextualizes someone’s behavior, preferences and communication style. These details provide managers with guidance shaped around the individual they’re about to meet with, so they can walk into any conversation feeling more confident and prepared.

Confidence changes the outcome of a hard conversation as much as preparation does. Managers who know how someone is likely to respond can stay steady when the conversation gets uncomfortable, instead of losing their footing.

Here’s how AI with embedded behavioral context can improve the same common breakdowns mentioned earlier:

  • Flagging an employee’s tendency toward defensiveness in advance lets a manager walk in ready for that reaction, avoiding the need to improvise after it happens.
  • Surfacing how much context a specific employee needs before receiving criticism means a manager can have a more tailored approach and build that in from the start of the conversation.
  • Showing how direct feedback tends to land with a specific person gives a manager language likely to be read as constructive while still delivering harder truths.

So how do organizations and their HR teams build that kind of behavioral infrastructure?

What HR should build first to scale behavioral support

Most organizations already have behavioral data sitting in assessment results, performance reviews and manager notes, but that data rarely gets translated into something a manager can use before a hard conversation.

HR’s first job is turning what’s already known about how someone communicates, processes feedback or responds under pressure into a clear framework for specific conversation types. That might mean a playbook for delivering critical feedback that flags when an employee needs processing time before responding, or one for managing team conflict that notes whether someone receives feedback better with context upfront or the issue stated directly.

Once those frameworks exist, AI built with more human context, grounded in validated behavioral assessment data, can carry them to every manager. That’s different from general-purpose AI, which has no read on the person a manager is about to sit across from. Behavioral intelligence gives HR’s frameworks somewhere to live, something a manager pulls up in the moment, without HR needing to be part of the conversation.

Starting with one conversation type, proving the guidance holds up, then expanding gives HR a way to scale behavioral support without waiting for a companywide rollout.

Leaders feeling confident in HR’s coaching and managers feeling supported are two different things, and more meetings won’t close the space between them. Closing it takes AI built with more human context behind it, something every manager can reach on their own in the moment they need it most.

The full picture of where leaders and managers disagree, and what managers say would actually help, is in the report. Get the 2026 AI and People Leadership Report.

You finish the PI Behavioral Assessment and a label comes back. Maybe you’re a Maverick, or a Collaborator, or one of the other 15 Reference Profiles. Most people read the description, nod at the parts that fit, and move on. Fewer stop to ask how the label got picked in the first place.

The answer is simpler than most people expect. It also clears up the thing that confuses teams most, which is why two coworkers with nearly identical results can walk away with different profiles.

Your pattern comes first

The Behavioral Assessment measures four factors: Dominance, Extraversion, Patience, and Formality. Your results place you somewhere on each one, and those four placements together make up your behavioral pattern.

The pattern is the real result. Your Reference Profile is shorthand for it, a name you can use in a meeting instead of reading out four factor placements.

Neighborhoods and addresses

Here’s a useful way to picture it. Your pattern is your exact street address, and your Reference Profile is the neighborhood that address sits in.

Plenty of addresses share a neighborhood. Two Persuaders won’t have identical patterns. They’re close enough to share a name, and sharing a name is all the profile promises.

How the match is made

Each of the 17 Reference Profiles has a prototype, a typical pattern that sits at the center of that neighborhood. When you finish the assessment, PI places your four factor scores on a common scale and measures how far your pattern is from each of the 17 prototypes, using straight-line distance.

Whichever prototype is closest becomes your Reference Profile. Nobody reviews your results and picks a label for you, and the software isn’t reading the visual shape of your graph. Because it’s a distance calculation, the same pattern gets the same profile every time.

Why near twins get different profiles

This is the part that trips people up. You and a colleague compare results, your patterns look almost the same, and yet you’re a Controller and they’re an Analyzer.

You’re both standing near the edge between two neighborhoods. A small difference in a single factor is enough to make a different prototype mathematically closer. It’s like living on a street where the zip code changes halfway down the block: your neighbor across the road gets a different postmark, even though you both shop at the same grocery store.

If that’s you, read both profile descriptions. People who sit near a boundary usually recognize themselves in each one, which is exactly what the math would predict.

The four groups

PI sorts the 17 Reference Profiles into four groups, and each group has its own shape in the software.

GroupShapeGeneral tendenciesReference Profiles
AnalyticalGearTask-focused and fast-paced, more decisive and independent than socially expressiveAnalyzer, Controller, Specialist, Strategist, Venturer
SocialHexagonPeople-oriented and outgoingAltruist, Captain, Collaborator, Maverick, Persuader, Promoter
StabilizingTriangleSteady, detailed, and drawn to structureAdapter, Artisan, Guardian, Operator
PersistentCircleTask-oriented and deliberate, with a strong need for stabilityIndividualist, Scholar

How to use your Reference Profile

Reference Profiles are good at starting a conversation. They give a team a shared vocabulary for coaching, onboarding, and working out why two people keep talking past each other.

They’re less good at the detail. When the conversation turns specific, like how to give someone feedback or whether a person fits a role, go back to the four factor placements. The neighborhood tells people roughly where you live. Your pattern tells them which house is yours, what color the door is, and whether there’s a garden gnome by the steps.

To see all 17 side by side, browse the Reference Profiles. For the full methodology, read the introduction to Reference Profiles.

The PI Job Assessment™ pinpoints the behavioral traits and cognitive ability someone would need to be successful in a given role. The PI Behavioral Assessment helps you determine if someone has the right personality for the job. And the PI Cognitive Assessment helps you understand the speed at which someone learns new information. Together, these PI hiring assessment tools increase your ability to predict candidate success.

Sure, you could ask a candidate a question like: Would you speak up for patient safety or choose the safe response of saying nothing? But when you ask leading questions like this one, you’re feeding the candidate the right answer. They’ll tell you what they think you want to hear. And that’s no good for anyone.

Often, hiring managers choose the candidate with the most experience. That person might also have the right personality and the required cognitive ability. But unless you collect these candidate data points, you really have no idea. You’re trusting your gut and making a guess.

What is the PI Behavioral Assessment?

Of all our workplace assessments, the most well-known is The Predictive Index Behavioral Assessment (BA). That’s because it’s been around for a long time! In fact, PI’s founder, the late Arnold Daniels, created it in the 1950s. Since then, the BA has been updated—and thousands of companies around the world have used it.

Unlike other personality tests, the PI Behavioral Assessment is scientifically-validated for workplace use. This is true for most any job, most any work environment, and most any industry worldwide. In 2018, it was certified by the DNV GL; this means the BA meets the strict guidelines of leading psychology experts at the EFPA. 

While the BA began as a hiring tool, companies now use BA data for many purposes. These include promoting employees, improving team dynamics, boosting productivity, and more.

Here are 10 facts about the PI Behavioral Assessment:

  1. When used for hiring, it’s used in conjunction with the PI Job Assessment. 
  2. The BA takes only six minutes to complete (on average).
  3. It’s an untimed assessment.
  4. Assessment takers receive two lists of adjectives.
  5. The BA is a free-choice, stimulus-response assessment tool.
  6. Candidates can take it in the language of choice.
  7. It measures four behavioral drives: Dominance, Extraversion, Patience, and Formality.
  8. The BA is a good indicator of a person’s workplace behavior.
  9. After someone takes the BA, they get their unique behavioral pattern. 
  10. Assessment takers are also assigned one of 17 Reference Profiles.

Hear what Jim Koch, Co-Founder of Boston Beer Company, said about using the BA to hire:

Jim Koch on the Behavioral Assessment

What is the PI Cognitive Assessment?

The PI Cognitive Assessment (CA) is a hiring assessment. The BA predicts future job performance in terms of behavioral fit. The CA predicts future job performance in terms of how fast someone will catch on, understand complexity, and figure things out. 

Cognitive ability is widely considered one of the best predictors of job performance.

Different roles and work environments require different cognitive abilities. An entry-level associate with no direct reports and basic protocols to follow won’t need to learn or process information too quickly. But a director tasked with acting on complex data and devising a multi-year strategy will need a higher cognitive score. 

For this reason, we urge clients to never use the PI platform to set one baseline cognitive target. In doing so, you could reject candidates who might be an excellent job fit simply because they didn’t meet an arbitrary target. Instead, use the PI Job Assessment to set a cognitive target based on the role and work environment. 

Here are 10 facts about the PI Cognitive Assessment:

  1. It’s used in conjunction with the PI Job Assessment. 
  2. The assessment takes 12 minutes to complete. 
  3. It’s a timed assessment.
  4. Each candidate experiences a unique set of questions.
  5. We encourage assessment takers to complete practice tests in advance. 
  6. Questions span three categories: numerical, abstract, and verbal.
  7. Assessment takers have the chance to answer 50 questions.
  8. The goal is to complete as many correct answers as possible within 12 minutes.
  9. We designed the CA to minimize cheating.
  10. There are no “good” or “bad” scores; view CA results in terms of job requirements.

We encourage clients to share the results of the behavioral assessment with candidates and employees. But we discourage the sharing of cognitive scores. 

How to use behavioral assessment data outside of hiring

You’ve learned how to use the PI Behavioral Assessment to predict job fit when hiring. But you can use the people data collected via this quick six-minute assessment for so much more!

Promotions, managing, and improving team dynamics

Many companies promote top-performing individual contributors. And then they discover they’re terrible at managing others. Typically, one of two things is happening.

First, they lack the behavioral traits needed to manage well. And they aren’t willing or able to stretch beyond their comfort zone to be who the role needs them to be. Or second, they lack self-awareness of how their behavior affects their direct reports.

In either case, the PI platform can help. Here are two best practices:

1. Follow the same protocol for promotions as you would for new hires. If you’re interested in promoting an existing employee, use the PI Job Assessment to pinpoint the behavioral traits needed for the role. Then see if the employee’s behavioral pattern is a match. Probe into any behavioral gaps with the provided customized structured interview questions. This will help the employee understand how and where they’d need to stretch—and if they even want to.

2. All managers can use the PI platform to access the PI Inspire solution. Within PI Inspire, managers can leverage the Relationship Guide, Manager Strategy Guide to:

  • Help two teammates work more effectively together
  • Learn how to accommodate employees’ individual preferences
  • Uncover why employees are working together but not reaching their goals

As long as the manager and their direct reports have completed the behavioral assessment, their data is in the software. This means it can be used to build self-awareness, communicate better, etc.

How does The Predictive Index work?

Ensuring fit between the business strategy and senior leaders

We created the PI Design solution to help business leaders understand how their team’s behavioral style (or “Team Type“) aligns with the team’s strategic goals. 

Step one is administering the behavioral assessment to each team member. From there, the software plots each person onto one quadrant: Innovation & Agility, Teamwork & Employee Experience, Process & Precision, and Results & Discipline. Next, the software assigns the team a Team Type, which describes your team’s collective behavioral style.

Step two is selecting your team’s strategic goals from a list. The big ah-ha moment? Seeing how aligned (or misaligned) your team is to its strategic goals. From there, you get tips to de-risk execution so you can move forward with confidence. 

Watch the PI Design software tour. 

Using The Predictive Index at your company

Now you know how the Predictive Index “tests” work. And you might be eager to learn how you could use them to solve your unique business challenges. Request a demo to speak to a talent optimization consultant who can walk you through the software and answer any questions.

Request a Demo

9,000+ companies trust The Predictive Index to create dream teams.

See how PI’s Talent Optimization Platform can help your company hire with certainty, inspire your teams, and sustain lasting employee engagement.

Please use a business email.

I would like to receive marketing emails from The Predictive Index. By submitting my information, I agree to be subject to PI’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

By submitting your information, you agree to be subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Get Paid For Your Feedback

Join our research program today and get paid for your feedback. Earn an Amazon gift card of up to $100 for each session you attend. You’ll get a first look at what we’re working on, and you’ll get to influence and improve our website.

Join the Program Now

Leadership tips and HR content worth sharing.

Join 150K+ business and HR leaders. One email a month.

THE LATEST FROM OUR BLOG


Copy link