Your behavioral data did its job at hiring — then you stopped using it

Most companies collect behavioral data during hiring, then shelve it right as it gets useful. Here’s how to put it to work in everyday management.


Over 75% of employers use skills tests during hiring, and about 80% of the Fortune 500 use personality assessments. By the time a new hire walks in the door, organizations already have rich behavioral data on who that person is and how they work best.

Then that data gets shelved — right as it becomes valuable.

Our Motivation at Work survey finds employee motivation is strong at the outset, with 78% of employees starting their current role motivated. But it fades fast: Only 16% told us their work feels meaningful. That’s not a coincidence. When behavioral data stops being used in the hiring decision, personalized management goes by the wayside.

Organizations have missed out on key data that could improve motivation and productivity. The fix requires treating behavioral data as a continuous input, embedded into how managers communicate, develop and support their people from day one.

Management strategies are getting generic

When we asked employees what would most improve their motivation, they pointed to clearer priorities, more recognition, fewer meetings and more autonomy — all responsibilities that managers control. Instead, most leaders default to generic, one-size-fits-all approaches rather than individualized ones.

When leaders ignore key behavioral context, employees feel unseen and unmotivated, and leaders unintentionally drive burnout. One recent Harvard Business Review study found that managers are more likely to overburden their most motivated employees. Because they appear enthusiastic, capable and willing, they get assigned more extraneous tasks. And it’s making them like their jobs less.

The assumption behind this is flawed twice over: that motivated employees will welcome any work thrown at them, and that loving a job protects against burnout. Neither is true. In reality, organizations are giving their best people a reason to disengage, which is costing the world economy an estimated $10 trillion in lost productivity.

Part of the problem is that managers are often leading without any individualized context for what actually motivates, drains or supports each employee. Even organizations that collect behavioral insights during hiring rarely continue using them once someone joins the team.

Abandoning behavioral data post-hire only compounds this disengagement crisis. It’s time organizations start using it for what it’s designed to do.

What behavioral data is actually designed for

Most companies treat behavioral assessments and data as a hiring tool when their purpose achieves much more.

Every person at work is driven by something — a need for autonomy, structure, speed, connection or precision. Those drives aren’t situational. They shape how someone processes information, responds to feedback, collaborates under pressure and receives recognition. They’re present on day one and every day after. A behavioral profile captures all of it.

That’s the intelligence organizations are sitting on. When it stays in the applicant tracking system, managers are left leading without the very context that predicted success in the first place. They default to generic communication, one-size-fits-all recognition and gut-feel feedback, none of which accounts for what actually drives the person in front of them.

The result is friction that compounds quietly in the form of missed signals, misread behaviors and employees who feel like they’re managed by policy rather than known as people. Engagement doesn’t crater overnight. It erodes in the gap between what behavioral data could tell a manager and what that manager actually knows.

That data should still be working post-hire, shaping how managers communicate, give feedback and motivate their teams every single day.

What using behavioral data post-hire looks like

Behavioral data has an important role in daily management. Acting on it helps with:

  • Guiding cross-functional relationships. Not everyone processes conflict, feedback or pressure the same way. When managers understand the behavioral drives of people across teams, they can adjust how they communicate, which reduces friction before it starts and builds the kind of trust that makes collaboration sustainable.
  • Managing more effectively. Generic feedback lands differently depending on who’s receiving it. Behavioral drives tell managers how each person prefers to be recognized, directed and challenged, so the guidance they give actually sticks rather than getting filtered out or misread.
  • Referencing profiles within the flow of work. The value of behavioral data compounds in small moments: a 1:1 agenda, a tense team meeting, a conversation that could go sideways. Having that context on hand means managers can show up prepared instead of reactive.
  • Personalizing development. Growth paths built on generic competency benchmarks rarely reflect how a person actually operates. Behavioral data surfaces what energizes each employee and where they’re most likely to thrive, making development conversations more honest and more useful for both sides.

Manage the distinctive quality in each individual, and motivation and engagement will become a byproduct.

What changes when you use behavioral data

When behavioral data informs the day-to-day, manager relationships become more effective. Communication gets cleaner. And employees managed as unique contributors leave work feeling understood and supported.

Organizations that replace guesswork with data-backed insight stop chasing engagement and start producing it. Higher retention, stronger team performance and more consistent leadership will follow. And with AI surfacing the right insights at the right moment, that’s no longer a practice that requires managers to remember every profile or dig through a report. It becomes part of how they already work.

Put your behavioral data to work with AI-powered insights that give managers a science-backed foundation for understanding what drives each person and how to act on it in real time.


Leadership tips and HR content worth sharing.

Join 150K+ business and HR leaders. One email a month.

THE LATEST FROM OUR BLOG


Copy link