Storytelling Skills That Set Managers Apart (feat. Johanna Walker)

Storytelling isn’t a performance trick or a “nice-to-have” for leaders who like to talk. It’s the fastest way to move a team, align a room, and make people care about work that might otherwise feel abstract. Most managers reach for dashboards, memos, and productivity systems when alignment breaks down. But for Johanna Walker, public speaking and storytelling coach and founder of Women Who Speak, the real gap isn’t strategy; it’s the absence of a story that makes the strategy matter.

In this episode, Matt Poepsel sits down with Johanna Walker, founder of Women Who Speak and the Speakers Playground, to dig into why the most ordinary moments make the most powerful stories, why managers who skip the story lose the room before they even start, and how the leaders who can communicate with presence and emotional honesty will hold a real edge in an AI-shaped workplace. Johanna makes the case that storytelling is not a talent you either have or don’t, it’s a muscle. And like any muscle, it gets built through discomfort, repetition, and a willingness to feel a little awkward before you feel confident. Together, they explore what it takes to notice, shape, and deliver stories that move people from passive listeners to committed teammates. 

In this episode, you’ll learn:

• Story Is the Moving Walkway: Without a story connecting people to the why, teams move more slowly, buy in less, and fill the gaps with their own assumptions.
• Stakes Drive Every Story: A good story isn’t about what happened; it’s about what someone wanted, and whether they got it. That uncertainty is what makes people lean in.
• The Treasure Chest Habit: Stories don’t require epic experiences. The benign, specific moments of daily work life are often the most compelling, if you’re paying attention.
• Go For Awkward: Building a storytelling culture on your team will feel uncomfortable at first. That discomfort is the signal you’re actually creating something new, not the signal to stop.

Highlights: 

(00:00) Meet Johanna Walker 

(01:47) Why managers don’t have time NOT to tell stories 

(04:08) How story connects people to purpose 

(05:02) Finding stories in ordinary moments 

(09:21) What makes a story tick: character, goal, stakes 

(15:15) Story templates as a starting point 

(18:21) Why storytelling feels unnatural at work 

(20:12) How to build a team storytelling culture 

(24:38) Are You Smarter than AI trivia question

(25:50) Engineers, dinner, and the question that changed the room

Resources: 

Follow Johanna on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/johannawalkerspeaking/ 

Visit Johanna’s website: https://johannawalker.com 

Follow Matt on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mattpoepsel/ 

Subscribe to The Predictive Index on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/ThePredictiveIndex

Created in partnership with Share Your Genius: shareyourgenius.com